Ways to Protect Yourself from Lawsuits on Your Rental Property: Umbrella Insurance vs. LLC

male insurance agent covering paper family, car and home with umbrella cutout at tableOne of the most important things for landlords to worry about in the world of real estate business is protecting their personal assets from possible lawsuits against investment property. A popular way to get this kind of safety is to set up a Limited Liability Company (LLC) or an umbrella insurance policy. But which one is a better way to protect yourself? In this blog post, we’ll compare and contrast the two so you can make a better choice.

Umbrella Insurance

Umbrella insurance is a type of liability insurance that covers claims which go beyond your regular insurance policies, like your homeowner’s, car, or business insurance. It is designed to go into effect when the limit on a basic insurance policy has been hit.

Pros of Umbrella Insurance

Limited Liability Companies (LLCs)

An LLC is a type of business entity that combines the tax benefits of a partnership or single proprietorship with the limited liability of a corporation. This structure can give you a strong layer of protection for your personal assets that is different from your business.

Pros of LLCs

Cons of LLCs


Umbrella insurance and creating an LLC can give you more protection from lawsuits on your rental properties, but they do so in different ways. Umbrella insurance is a type of extended liability insurance that can protect you from different claims. An LLC keeps your personal and business assets separate, which can protect your personal assets if you get sued.

Whether you should form an LLC or buy umbrella insurance relies on your personal situation, how much risk you’re willing to take, and the rules of the state where you do business. It’s important to talk to a lawyer or insurance agent to figure out which option is best for your specific case.

Why Not Have Both?

In the end, both ways may be part of a well-rounded plan to protect your assets. A limited liability company (LLC) gives you strong legal protection, and umbrella insurance could give you more financial safety. When you use both, they can work together to make a full shield that protects your investment from more possible legal problems. But, as always, the most important thing is to know all of your choices well and make a decision that fits your situation.


"I have had the pleasure of working with the Keyes Law Group these past months. To date, Mr. Keyes has been a great asset to our family; helping to plan a trust and the appropriate tax strategies for us and the next generation. What has worked very well for my wife and I is the time Mr. Keyes has devoted to not only hearing our financial planning concerns, but to also take the necessary time to explain and offer options for us to consider. We have worked with tax attorneys and financial consultants over the years. For us, a successful relationship is one of the key factors that we strive for. Working with the Keyes Law Group has been a very good fit for us as we work to get our financial affairs in order." -- RY
"I can’t say enough great things about Keyes Law Group! They are thorough, caring, and extremely efficient! I send everyone I know to them for Estate Planning! They took such great care of my family and they have earned my business forever! Look no further than Keyes Law Group if you want a seamless process and to cover all bases for your estate! They aren’t just Estate Attorneys; they are family!" -SL
"The patience with helping us achieve our goal and the patience in breaking down the legalese into simple language that we could understand was very beneficial. We felt we were very well taken care of." -GR
"We truly appreciate your thoughts, ideas and time. I very much value your expertise and look forward to more dialogue about best ways to move forward, build healthier relationships with our children and their children and to pass on our values to the degree we are able." -R.Y.
"I was able to have a honest dialog with such an understanding, compassionate, and caring human being. Thank you." -Y.H.
"I've had the opportunity to work with Elijah for several years now. I started during a challenging situation with my mother and he was terrific. I'd say he's very responsive, reliable and exceptionally fair. Also very empathetic. It's refreshing to engage with him and feel that I'm being well taken care of and my needs are being met. His staff is also lovely and overall super accommodating." -I.S.
"It is very important to research and choose wisely when looking for an estate planning attorney. Did you know that the California State Bar Board of Legal Specialization has a unique recognition for attorneys who go beyond the regular requirements to practice Estate Planning? Elijah Keyes has this designation; Certified Estate Planning Specialist. He is extremely well versed with this specific area of law and is a strong advocate for his clients in estate planning, including establishing living trusts, wealth planning and family transfers, dynasty trusts, conservatorships, special needs trusts, elder law medi-cal benefits and planning, trust administration and probate. Thank you Elijah, for being a trusted resource for us and for our clients!" -M.H.
"Keyes Law Group helped our family through a very difficult time with estate planning. He's honest, transparent and genuinely cares about his clients. His own personal experiences have shaped his approach in working with people - especially older folks who might be more mistrusting. He can finesse difficult conversations with ease and for that, I'm forever grateful. 100% recommend!" -Y.V.
"Elijah was very helpful with editing our family trust after my wife passed away. He answered all my question in a timely manner and if he did not know the answer he found out quickly. He would take time out of day to reassure me that he had everything under control. He took his time to explain why he worded the trust the way he did and that I understood what it meant. Will use him again when the trust needs to updated." -D.